Best Pool Cleaner Reviews Of 2023 – In-Ground and Above Ground Pool Vacs Guide

By Mary | Updated: March 24, 2023

Having a swimming pool with sparkling clear water is one thing that is possible to achieve but will require time and effort on your part. This means that you need to have the right cleaning equipment that will make it easy to maintain the water’s cleanliness.

In my case, to be able to do this, I use a high-quality vacuum cleaner.  I had read a variety of reviews before I decided to be assured that it will not lead to frustration. I suggest that you also do the same before you settle with an option.

Here’s a comparison table for 10 popular pool cleaners with relative price ratings:

Pool Cleaner Type Pool Size Hose Length Cleaning Cycle Price Rating
Dolphin Nautilus CC Plus Robotic Pool Cleaner Robotic Up to 50 ft 50 ft 2 hours $$$$
Zodiac Baracuda G3 W03000 Advanced Suction Side Cleaner Suction Side Up to 32 ft 39 ft N/A $$
Polaris Vac-Sweep 360 Pressure Side Pool Cleaner Pressure Side Up to 31 ft 31 ft N/A $$$
Hayward W3PVS20GST Poolvergnuegen Pool Cleaner Suction Side Up to 20 x 40 ft 33 ft N/A $$$
Dolphin Premier Robotic Pool Cleaner Robotic Up to 50 ft 60 ft 3 hours $$$$$
Pentair LL505G Kreepy Krauly Legend Pressure-Side Inground Pool Cleaner Pressure Side Up to 20 x 40 ft 31 ft N/A $$$$
Hayward W3PHS41CST AquaNaut 400 Suction Pool Cleaner Suction Side Up to 20 x 40 ft 40 ft N/A $$$
Zodiac MX6 In-Ground Suction Side Pool Cleaner Suction Side Up to 30 ft 36 ft N/A $$
XtremepowerUS Automatic Suction Vacuum-generic Climb Wall Pool Cleaner Suction Side Up to 30 ft 33 ft N/A $
Hayward W3TVP500C TriVac 500 Pressure Pool Cleaner Pressure Side Up to 20 x 40 ft 30 ft N/A $$$$

In-Ground Pool Vacuum Cleaners

In the rest of this article, I will provide you with valuable insights regarding the best in-ground pool vacuum cleaners available in the market today. This will make it a lot easier for you to reach a decision regarding the brand and model that you should choose.

Zodiac Polaris

One of the products that I can recommend from this brand is the Polaris Vac-Sweep 280. With this model’s powerful dual jets and booster pump, cleaning all in-ground pools will not be a challenging task to complete. If your pool is made from vinyl, the TanTrax model will prove to be the best choice for you.

Another model that can also be given consideration is the Polaris Vac 380. It has three powerful jets that make sure of its powerful performance. While this unit can help keep the pool clean, this will also function in the distribution of chemicals and heat.

The Polari Vac-Sweep 360 will also be a model that can prove to be worth your money. Regardless of the material that the pool is made of, whether it is vinyl, fiberglass, or gunite, this model will deliver the same high-quality cleaning performance. It comes with a 31-foot hose that makes it able to clean even larger pools.

You can read more about the Polaris vacuums in my Polaris pool cleaner review.

Baracuda Automatic

If Baracuda is your brand of choice, one of the models I can suggest is the Baracuda G3. I find it useful because it only has a single moving part, which means that it will require less maintenance and durable.

The Baracuda G2 is also an option that will not lead to regret. One of its best features is the suction side cleaner that makes it possible to clean the in-ground pool’s side walls. Once the product is taken out of its packaging, you will surely not need to spend a lot of time putting the pieces together before it is easy to use.

Lastly, I also found the Baracuda MX8 as an option that is being worth taken into account. It is equipped with cyclonic vacuum technology that can capture the maximum amount of dirt without difficulty. It also has X-Drive technology that makes it able to cover a wider area.

Pentair Kreepy Krauly

The Kreepy Krauly Classic is perhaps the most popular from this brand. It has a dive float directional system that ensures extensive coverage as it cleans the entire pool. It also comes with an automatic valve that provides the proper water flow to the area that requires cleaning.

In many reviews that I have a head in the past, another product that has often been given positive feedback is the Pentair K70405. One thing that makes it popular is the rugged design, making it able to handle even the toughest cleaning jobs.

Lastly, you might also want to take a look at the Pentair GW9500. It has a one-of-a-kind mechanism for turning that makes it more efficient when cleaning pools. It is also common for many users to commend the fact that it does not require too much effort and knowledge to use.


From this brand, one model that I can recommend is the Hayward PoolVac XL. It has an exceptional filtration system that makes it reliable. Also, it has the Aqua Pilot technology. This makes it able to perform more efficiently compared to the traditional models available in the marketplace.

More so, you might also want to take a look at the Hayward Navigator Pro. It has an excellent design, which is specifically apparent with the hydro-dynamic head. This is not only stylish but also highly functional. The installation will take less than 10 minutes and will not require the use of any tools.

The Hayward Tiger Shark is another model that I see to be exceptional, especially given its high ratings. Among others, it is known for energy efficiency. To add, it has a patented system that makes it a breeze to clean. Like the other models from Hayward, it is known for its quiet performance.

Above-Ground Pool Vacuums

With the use of the best above-ground pool vacuums, it will be possible for you to maintain your swimming pool’s cleanliness, which will make it more enjoyable for family and friends to dip into such. After all, no one would want to be swimming among the dirt and debris.

There are different brands and models of above-ground pool robotic cleaners that are currently available in the market. Because of the diversity of options, it becomes harder to choose the best among them. It is essential to carefully evaluate these choices to end up with a decision that you will not regret making.

The rest of this article will identify some of the most prominent brands in the marketplace, which will provide you with valuable help in choosing the most ideal option. It seeks to give you a snapshot of what can be expected from some of the available brands.


Among other things, one that has been highly commended by the users of such is that it is an affordable option. It has a reasonable price, but it does not compensate for quality. This will provide you with an assurance that you can expect the same level of superior performance that Baracuda is known for.

Convenience is another major factor in why this brand is a popular option in the marketplace. Upon purchase, the unit is already pre-installed, eliminating the need to have them manually put together once the package is received. In fact, no tools will ever be required to start enjoying its functionality.

Many have expressed their high level of satisfaction over the fact that they do not require heavy maintenance. It is a breeze to keep the sweepers in their best possible condition, despite the prolonged period of frequent use.

Aqua Products

The best thing about the models from this brand is that they are robotic. This just means that there will be less need for you to exert effort and time in its use. It has an intelligent design, which will allow the pool vacuum cleaner to function on its own, requiring minimal intervention on your part.

The Pool Rover Jr. is one of the most prominent models from Aqua Products. It is most known for its ability to trap and filter even the tiniest of algae, including at least 2 microns in size. It is also equipped with a powerful 24-volt motor, which provides a guarantee of its reliable performance.

The Pool Rover S2-40 is another possible option that can be taken into account. It has a large onboard bag, making sure of its ability to vacuum more from what can cause dirt and damages to your pool. With the help of this product, the water in your above-ground pool will always be as fresh as possible.

Pentair Kreepy Krauly

When asked about what makes this brand the right choice, many people would say that it would be the fact that it has long-term functionality. One reason for such is that there is only one moving and operational part: the flapper. This means that there are no parts that will require service and replacement in the long run.

Also, the true random pattern coverage is another feature that is worth noting about this brand. It merely means that it can handle a broader coverage of the pool, making it impossible to miss any portion. It makes sure that the dirt and debris will all be trapped.

The scrubbing power of the above-ground pool cleaners from this manufacturer is also worth giving emphasis. It has a powerful brushing mechanism, primarily because of the dual band of bristles, making sure that the surface is left clean.

 Above-Ground vs In-Ground Pool Vacuums

The vacuum that you should use for cleaning will depend highly on the type of pool you have. If you have a permanent pool dug into the ground, you should choose the in-ground pool vacuum.

On the other hand, if you have one of those commercially available pools that stand atop the surface, you should use the above-ground pool vacuum cleaners.

If there is one thing that is the same for both types of models, it would be the fact that they utilize the same underlying technology, which makes it possible to deliver superior cleaning performance.

The in-ground vacuum cleaners are designed specifically to clean submerged pools or permanent and often built with concrete. Typically, the pool cleaners that fall within this category can handle up to 8 feet of depth.

Compared to in-ground pool cleaners, cleaners for above-ground pools hold the advantage of being more practical since it is cheaper. However, take note that above-ground pools require more attention in being cleaned because they often lack pumps and filters, helping maintain their cleanliness.

When it comes to size, there is also a significant difference between the two. Above-ground vacs are generally smaller compared to in-ground pool cleaners. However, despite this, you can still expect the same level of effectiveness.

It is also important to note that these cleaners are explicitly made for vinyl-lined surfaces of the swimming pool and for flat-bottom pools characterized by the absence of a deep end. They also function slower.